The Ugly Underbelly of the Federal Government’s Carbon Tax

in Canada by

None of the federal government’s decisions have stirred up as much controversy in the past as its current carbon pricing scheme. Yet it still feels like we’re barely skimming the surface. There’s a lot that’s left to be discussed. And there’s a whole underbelly to the policy that’s not so pretty.

In theory, the concept of carbon tax seems pretty straightforward. The government needs to find ways to “save mother earth” and keep the environment clean. It comes up with a proposal to tax carbon consumption. The tax forces the people to be more efficient in their use of carbon.

But is it really that simple? Let’s see.

The gross inequity

At surface level analysis, like the one we just did above, the concept of carbon tax seems much too simple. In fact, it seems simplistic. And it is. One of the biggest problems when it comes to the carbon pricing scheme is the horrible inequality that comes with it.

The government wants to use the tax as a punitive action for the inefficient users of energy. It uses the tax to deter people from using energy inefficiently. Why is it, then, that those who are already efficient with their energy use need to pay the tax as well?

Who would answer that question?

Impact on energy

Many carbon tax policies, imposed by premiers like Kathleen Wynne, have been criticized for not being too effective when it comes to its intended consequence; saving the environment.

How so? Well, the ultimate intent of the carbon tax is to reduce the total energy consumption. Yet there’s no credible evidence anywhere to support the fact that it does that. Let’s take commercial energy usage, for instance. All Wynne’s policies do is to push investment out of Ontario. It doesn’t shut down energy businesses for good. It moves them elsewhere.

And as far as the public is concerned, they won’t use less gas for their vehicles. They will just be more furious about using expensive gas.

Jason grew up on a farm in Saskatchewan and moved to work in the Alberta oil patch for the last 10 years, he has a sense of humor and open mind, his goal is to provide factual news across Canada and the United States on politics, he hopes one day to work for many publishing networks around the world.

1 Comment

  1. Why are willing to ‘KILL’ our economy, jobs, livelihood for a bunch of ‘wealthy environmentalists who fly around our world own big yachts, many houses -all of them that uses ‘FOSSIL FUEL’ to operate and maintain.

    If protesters in Canada are that concern about the environment should be the first to demonstrate their concern by: ‘NOT USING ANY MEANS OF FOSSIL FUEL OR ANYTHING CONNECTED TO FOSSIL FUEL. Instead they use fossil fuel just like everybody else who are, as they are called, ‘CLIMATE DENIERS.’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.